Athorn the Wonderkid wrote:
gsker1 wrote:
I want Kouta to play on, but he is not going to get the sort of money that wanker Alison is going on about.
I hope they come to some sort of agreement
I dont want this to sound like a Kouta bash, but why do you want Kouta to play on?
A. Performance / adds to the current team?
B. Mentor for current kids coming through (as per the Jim Wilson article)?
C. You feel better seeing him out there
D. It would be a shame for a Carlton Champion to finish up this way?
E. Inspirational leadership?
Any other reason? See, to me, C and D are irrelevant, A is arguable, E is false as he doesn't provide it and B he can do from the sidelines. I just dont get why we want a 34 year old to keep playing given where we are on the ladder and in our development.
Get off the funny stuff and for once judge a senior player with a modicum of respect and fair consideration for his contribution to this club.
A. He is in our best 18. He has a mature body which our other midfielders lack and we simply don't have enough quality mids next year to be competitive. His marking has improved in recent weeks and he can be a valuable part of rotations in 2007.
B. Definite mentor role to play - our last remaining premiership player and captain of the club. We have a thin experienced senior group as it is.
C & D. Irrelevant to the argument of is Kouta worth keeping an dhow much we should pay him. If the match committee deems him to be a required palyer then I'll accept that.
E. No other player in our side commands such respect for his past performances. We don't have any other clear leaders waiting in the wings to take over.