CARLTON V WEST COAST EAGLES
Subiaco Oval – Round 14, 2005

Team CARLTON
Position
Name #
Backs
Andrew Carrazzo 44 Luke Livingston 4 David Teague 15
Half backs
Ryan Houlihan 33 Bret Thornton 32 Cory McGrath 20
Centreline
Heath Scotland 29 Brett Johnson 10 Scott Camporeale 16
Half forwards
Troy Longmuir 21 Jarrad Waite 30 Matthew Lappin 12
Forwards
Lance Whitnall 8 Brendan Fevola 25 Kade Simpson 6
Followers
Chris Bryan 27 Anthony Koutoufides 43 Nick Stevens 24
Interchange:
Glen Bowyer 18 Callum Chambers 22 Ian Prendergast 28

Andrew Walker 1
Emergencies:
Justin Davies 7 Digby Morrell 3 Trent Sporn 36


In Luke Livingston - Returns after 1 match for the Northern Bullants
Troy Longmuir - Returns after 7 matches for the Northern Bullants
David Teague - Returns after 1 match for the Northern Bullants
Jarrad Waite - Was a late withdrawal against the Bulldogs in Round 13

Out Jordan Bannister - Omitted
Eddie Betts - Omitted
Justin Davies - Omitted
Trent Sporn - Omitted




Team Round 14: West Coast Eagles v Carlton
Game Date: Saturday, July 2, 2.10pm Subiaco Oval
Position Name # # #
Backs David Wirrpunda 44 Darren Glass 23 Adam Hunter 39
Half-backs Daniel Chick 17 Brent Staker 41 Tyson Stenglein 5
Centreline Drew Banfield 6 Ben Cousins 9 Michael Braun 10
Half-forwards Mark Nicoski 31 Ashley Hansen 29 Daniel Kerr 4
Forwards Phil Matera 33 Quinten Lynch 21 Andrew Embley 32
Ruck Dean Cox 20 Chris Judd 3 Chad Fletcher 7
Interchange Aaron Edwards 45 Brett Jones 38 Mark Seaby 14
Adam Selwood 37

Emergencies Sam Butler 26 Andrew McDougall 2 Matt Rosa 24

TEAM CHANGES

In: Nil
Out: Nil

_________________
Go Blues

thanks sas87!

_________________
|♥♥♥♥♥♥| http://www.blueseum.org |♥♥♥♥♥♥|

have to say...it looks a whole lot better than last game...

anyone know whats going on with french?

_________________
R A D I C A L B R O T H E R S

Inspired by the One-Minute Sculptures of Erwin Wurm

"All in all is all we are..."

Yeah I reckon that structurally it looks a lot better, and the forward line looks more dangerous...

Future can't be looking too good for Sporn, Davies and Bannister...

_________________
Formerly Blues-Back2003.

Banno's dad won't be happy, either

4 great ins and 4 good outs, even though I love Eddie he could do with a VFL stint.

And kh wasn't the Banno's dad thing a hoax?

Shocked.

After his game in Bendigo, Chambers getting promoted is a complete joke ... I thought putting him in the best was leading to this as there was no other way to justify his promotion than to try and fool the general public that he played a blinder last weekend.

Subiaco is a big ground and you want runners but if a player isn´t in form what´s the point of promoting him? Hopefully he lifts playing against his old team but he has alot of improving from a very average performance at the VFL level.

Betts is unlucky.

Not sure what you mean Blue 2. Didn't Chambers play against the Bulldogs? Do you mean Longmuir?

Good to see waite back and broken record but what on earth was the decision to drop livo against the dogs - not play him in the vfl and also
play bannister against dogs not give him game time and then drop him
We really need french back and hopefully french /bryan combination we be a winner going forward

Frank,

Who would Livo have played on in Darwin? We were slow enough as it is

You´re right Trem! Missed that game. Apologies.

He also played at the VFL level last weekend and was average at best, doesnt deserve a spot in the team IMO. It says alot for the quality of our list that I´ve just been thinking "then who does" and I cant come up with someone. Morell is the most obvious I guess but probably not suited to this game. Fisher´s not ready, perhaps Russell. Both Smith and Setanta do but of course they are rookies.

Longmuir on the other hand was excellent against the Bendigo Bombers and should be repaid with promotion.

Like Chambers but think he needs to go back and prove himself at VFL level.

I got a thing about balance,and this side is a very balanced side.If ever Chambers and TLo are going to do something,then back in the west is the place as well as time.Chambers adds run,and TLo adds marking power....Reckon without a doubt the key to beating the weagles is to curtail the big three of Judd,Cousins and that underated but lethal Chad Fletcher.Those three are the heartbeat of the team and you apply massive pressure to them and hope to christ the others collapse around them.Getting Kouta,Campo and Stevens to play nullifying roles would be my go.Takes the best to beat the best.No good trying to plug all the leaks,just the main ones.

_________________
All my dangerous friends

I think frank's problem is that Livo was dropped from the team, but still travelled to Darwin, thereby missing out on a game altogether. Can kinda see where he is coming from.

Pleased to see Simpson is being persisted with, for the time being at least.

_________________
Click here to follow TalkingCarlton on twitter
TalkingCarlton Posting Rules

PRENDA IS STILL IN?????????????????????????????????

anyone we were beaten badly in any case - why not try him at chf if lance wasnt firing
Why not try playing him as third marking forward given waite was out
Why not see if he could have curtailed a smaller forward

Did play in the VFL last week though. With Waite in doubt they neeeded to have 2 extras in case anyone else pulled out at the last minute.

No VFL game this week so no real chance for those not playing this week to press for selection next week.



Barney is still out!!!!

Not a good enough reason to keep Prenda in i'm affraid!

Prenda has done nothing all year, yet he is continually rewarded by given a spot in the side.
I'm 6'4"..........does that mean that i can gain a guaranteed spot because French is still out?

The last time Prenda was dropped.........the bullants had a bue and he was brought back in the week after. So he basically got a weeks holiday.

I'm starting to think that Prenda will still be on our list next year!

Who else can help out Bryan? Cox is the best ruckman in the league and no way will Bryan be able to play the whole match in the ruck.

I don't get why Betts gets dropped for Suby games???
I thought his pace would be required...plus the fact that allows us to keep a really open forward and let hi \m run onto the ball..let alone crumb from long bombs??

And Frank...agree with Bannister/ Livo last week. I literally saw Bannister at one ball up in Darwin...missed the TOG but someone said it was a handful of minutes....I don't get it?

I would've thought he'ld have the tank to tag a player THIS week...moreso than Bowyer...???

_________________
“Every single element of the Club has to be the best in the league, meticulously and methodically, and only by doing this will we be elite and challenge for number 17.”
Greg Lee

Bannister had 2 possesions in 62 minutes.