TalkingCarlton :: View topic

Now this bloke doesnt have a position at the Saints.
He plays second fiddle but i thought his game was marvelous again.. now that the Golden boy is out injured he is stepping up.
I came to think about what would a guy like Kosi be worth to us. ???

What would you give up to draft a REAL CHF especially a POWER CHF to this club.????
What would you offer him???

Personally for me????

Whatever it took...!!!!!!!

A long contract at a half a million Id pay for him to walk.

The only problem with Kosi is he is injury prone..

I saw the stat, he has missed 38 games so far in his career due to injury. Thats nearly 2 years of footy out of 4-5 years.

Can you image if we gave everything to get him, pay big bucks and he couldn't get on the ground.... The saints supporters would be calling him Hamill....

bosman wrote:

Nah he is only 22 so he will be 27 when the 5 years are up... and id rather give him 500k then Campo or Lance.

His body wont start packing up till hes 27 to 28... but we need him.
Unless you can think of another power CHF and how we can bring him to the club.

Saints might be interested for picks 1 and 3 , but only might because it is a crap draft with none of the talent on offer half as as good as Kossi. :roll:

Hey PJ, it was a good game up intil half time. eh.

let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble.

If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton.

:roll:

garth p wrote:

Kosi will sign with St.Kilda.
That I have no doubt of.

If I were Murphy, I'd want to play with Carlton.
Why? Immediate game time.
If Murphy was at the Lions he'd have to wait probably 2-3 years before he played on a consistent basis.
Hard to break into a midfield of Hadley, Aker, Black, Voss, Lappin etc etc

Hey PJ, it was a good game up until half time. eh.

Let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble.

If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton.

:roll:

Yea, maybe you are right on Murphy, but the boy probably wants to play in a winning side occassionally

Not as rare as a captain for Carlton... thats a select group.. as a matter of fact its sooo select and rare that we cant find ours... :wink:

garth p wrote:

Murphy would rather play for Carlton.
If we cant get Kosi we can certainly drive up his price.

Its not like StKilda will ever win a premiership....

120 years one flag and 30 wooden spoons.

Cant argue with history. :wink:

Author:	Synbad [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 10:54 pm ]
Post subject:	Kosi
Now this bloke doesnt have a position at the Saints. He plays second fiddle but i thought his game was marvelous again.. now that the Golden boy is out injured he is stepping up. I came to think about what would a guy like Kosi be worth to us. ??? What would you give up to draft a REAL CHF especially a POWER CHF to this club.???? What would you offer him??? Personally for me???? Whatever it took...!!!!!!! A long contract at a half a million Id pay for him to walk.

Author:	phoenix johnson [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 10:57 pm ]
Post subject:	Re: Kosi
Synbad wrote: Now this bloke doesnt have a position at the Saints. He plays second fiddle but i thought his game was marvelous again.. now that the Golden boy is out injured he is stepping up. I came to think about what would a guy like Kosi be worth to us. ??? What would you give up to draft a REAL CHF especially a POWER CHF to this club.???? What would you offer him??? Personally for me???? Whatever it took...!!!!!!! A long contract at a half a million Id pay for him to walk. Agree. He can do what basically no one at our club, bar probably Fish, can do. And that is take a contested mark. The guy is a very, very good player. I'd offer him a 400k contract. St.Kilda would most definitely want a first round pick plus a player for him.

Author:	bluehammer [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 10:57 pm ]
Post subject:
Come on now Synbad, he's the CAPTAIN. The CAPTAIN of the St Kilda Football Club. Do you even know what a prestigious and rare title that is these days? He's in such a select group. Pull your head in.

Author:	billc3 [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:00 pm ]
Post subject:
to quote from Dossa and Joe..."whatever you're thinking...and double it!".... SAints have mismanaged him playing him in the ruck week in and out when he was 18 and then wondering why he was so injury prone....(done a josh fraser on him!)...I think though as he matures, he'll only get better... a will Reiwolt (which is scary!)

Author:	Synbad [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:00 pm ]
Post subject:
Not as rare as a captain for Carlton... thats a select group.. as a matter of fact its sooo select and rare that we cant find ours...

TalkingCarlton http://talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/

Kosi http://talkingcarlton.com/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=3591	Page 1 of 4

Author:	AGRO [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:00 pm ]
Post subject:
Time to ratify a 5 year contract - take it to the board Collo.

Author:	bosman [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:05 pm ]
Post subject:
The only problem with Kosi is he is injury prone.. I saw the stat, he has missed 38 games so far in his career due to injury. Thats nearly 2 years of footy out of 4-5 years. Can you image if we gave everything to get him, pay big bucks and he couldn't get on the ground.... The saints supporters would be calling him Hamill....

Author:	Synbad [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:09 pm ]
Post subject:
bosman wrote: The only problem with Kosi is he is injury prone.. I saw the stat, he has missed 38 games so far in his career due to injury. Thats nearly 2 years of footy out of 4-5 years. Can you image if we gave everything to get him, pay big bucks and he couldn't get on the ground.... The saints supporters would be calling him Hamill.... Nah he is only 22 so he will be 27 when the 5 years are up... and id rather give him 500k then Campo or Lance. His body wont start packing up till hes 27 to 28... but we need him. Unless you can think of another power CHF and how we can bring him to the club.

Author:	bosman [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:16 pm ]
Post subject:
Synbad wrote: bosman wrote: The only problem with Kosi is he is injury prone.. I saw the stat, he has missed 38 games so far in his career due to injury. Thats nearly 2 years of footy out of 4-5 years. Can you image if we gave everything to get him, pay big bucks and he couldn't get on the ground.... The saints supporters would be calling him Hamill.... Nah he is only 22 so he will be 27 when the 5 years are up... and id rather give him 500k then Campo or Lance. His body wont start packing up till hes 27 to 28... but we need him. Unless you can think of another power CHF and how we can bring him to the club. Only if he stays at CHF and doesn't play in the ruck.. Yep, he is worth 500K a year to us if he can play 22 games... The only thing we could offer is picks 1 or 3 for him, I can't see St Kilda being interested in any of our players or any other club as a matter of fact....

Author:	garth p [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:28 pm ]
Post subject:
Saints might be interested for picks 1 and 3 , but only might because it is a crap draft with none of the talent on offer half as as good as Kossi.

Author:	garth p [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:39 pm ]
Post subject:
Hey PJ, it was a good game up until half time. eh. Let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble. If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton.

Author:	Ponkstar [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:42 pm ]
Post subject:
Unfortunately, if we wanted to sell the club to him as the place to be we probably missed the opportunity today. right back at ya

Author:	garth p [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:45 pm ]
Post subject:
phoenix johnson wrote: garth p wrote: Hey PJ, it was a good game up intil half time. eh. let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble. If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton. Kosi will sign with St.Kilda. That I have no doubt of. If I were Murphy, I'd want to play with Carlton. Why? Immediate game time. If Murphy was at the Lions he'd have to wait probably 2-3 years before he played on a consistent basis. Hard to break into a midfield of Hadley, Aker, Black, Voss, Lappin etc etc Yea, maybe you are right on Murphy, but the boy probably wants to play in a winning side occassionally

Author:	Synbad [ Sun Jul 10, 2005 11:55 pm ]
Post subject:
garth p wrote: Hey PJ, it was a good game up until half time. eh. Let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble. If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton. Murphy would rather play for Carlton. If we cant get Kosi we can certainly drive up his price. Its not like StKilda will ever win a premiership.... 120 years one flag and 30 wooden spoons. Cant argue with history.

Page 1 of 4	All times are UTC + 10 hours
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/

Author:	thrylos7 [ Mon Jul 11, 2005 12:17 am ]
Post subject:
get him and give them what they want. not just he impressed me today but aint that luke ball a player.

Author:	Wojee [ Mon Jul 11, 2005 12:36 am ]
Post subject:
garth p wrote: Yea, maybe you are right on Murphy, but the boy probably wants to play in a winning side occassionally Hey I think you forgot something.

Author:	Aphrodite [ Mon Jul 11, 2005 1:42 am ]
Post subject:
Synbad wrote: Not as rare as a captain for Carlton... thats a select group.. as a matter of fact its sooo select and rare that we cant find ours... Synbad he's been spotted in Lonsdale St sipping "frappe" at Medallion .......... no no no NOT the Medallion club ...... The Medallion coffee lounge

Author:	Jarusa [ Mon Jul 11, 2005 7:55 am ]
Post subject:
Synbad wrote: garth p wrote: Hey PJ, it was a good game up until half time. eh. Let's be honest, if you were Kossi, would you be bailing on your mates to play with a rabble. If your were Murphy, would you want to play for the Lions or Carlton. Murphy would rather play for Carlton. If we cant get Kosi we can certainly drive up his price. Its not like StKilda will ever win a premiership.... 120 years one flag and 30 wooden spoons. Cant argue with history. Hey, watch out there Synbad, they look like statistics.