7dominator wrote:
TheSheik wrote:
Deano Supremo wrote:
:arrow: The emergence of Kade Simpson. Looks like he believes he can make it now.

The late season form of Adam Bentick. Hopefully he can take a step up next year.
If you are looking at the real positives for the season, they are the success stories. Two young guys who really hit their straps when finally given the chance and in doing so have given us all some genuine hope & excitement for the future.
I guess you will claim credit for them Sheik????...particularly when they were on your cracked/sacked listed earlier in the year????
"I did have to laugh when re-reading that thread how Bentick went from a "cracked" to a retain when he had'nt played a game for a month...Seems you were influenced by what you had read of his Bullants form...You are good at that???
The best interchange on the thread however was back in April....As a response to your early call for the near total demolition of the list.....
"DJ wrote:
Did you watch the game?
Sheik....
"Does it matter ??"
DJ again....
"Well that depends on how much credibiity you want to have."
Given your suddden about turn on Bentick and Simpson(add in Carrazzo ?) i look forward to your equally well informed diagnosis of our list...
Just a pity that you have, in your multitude of opiniated posts on our list, have based your observations on heresay and the sites..
Your recruitment suggestions will be eagerly awaited, particular your explanation of how the sacking of half our list will be replaced, particularly given that you only advocate the first 3 rounds.."no dregs from other Clubs"
I have noted your expectations that we will trade a number of players.That seems at odds with you observation of the worth of them?.i.e what is their currency and what do you get get for a 3rd/4th round swap...
Let me guess,Longmuirs,teaugues,Chambers of the world.The same ones you have been critical of the Club recruiting(Other Clubs dregs_inyour words)...The only trouble is that you operate with hindsight!
Heres a challenge for you Sheik.....give me the numbers that you are sacking or trading.....and balance them out with inflow???
Okay then smart-alec, I'll play your game.
From the original threadstarter :
CRACKED
Kade Simpson - has been there long enough, fire up or open to the highest bidder.
BACKED
Adam Bentick
So what's the problem with that ??? This was backed up later in the thread with :
Look, from where I sit, those are the players who will come under scrutiny and they have another 19 games to show why they should stay. My guess is that a fair few of them will be gone come season's end. The reason I say that is that we just don't have a premeirship winning list and to get one, we have to make changes and the only way to do that is make hard decisions. Mon Apr 11, 2005 9:16 pm
Opinions on players change constantly throughout a season subject to their form & the teams onfield fortunes. If we were to go back through some of the many threads on this forum I'm sure you'd find more of the the same.
That particular thread has run for a great deal of the season and it generated some interesting discussion from a wide variety of members on CSC. I'm still waiting to read any thread that you not only started, but where you have had the courage of your own convictions to have an opinion or make a prediction.
But hey, you just sit in the comfort zone and never ever stick your neck out by actually voicing your opinion, that way no-one will ever be able to criticise your comments.
http://www.csc.actebs.com.au/modules.ph ... sc&start=0