He'd be good as a runner.....don't forget he started all of this run and carry footy....

_________________
No ones listening till you make a mistake.

OUT: DeLuca, Russell and McLaren.

IN: Blue Wiggle, Red Wiggle and Yellow Wiggle.

Can't fit the Purple Wiggle in on two accounts:

1) Team Balance

2) Molley Meldrum has other ideas for him.

_________________
"The Ox is Slow but the Earth is Patient" and don't forget it!

Oops....sorry I forgot that there was a third reason why I can't fit the the Purple Wiggle into the line-up.......You can never wake the bastard up!

_________________
"The Ox is Slow but the Earth is Patient" and don't forget it!

You've got to be joking.
Surely Bannister and O'Hailpin coming in in the last 2 weeks have proven once and for all that the VFL best players mean didly squat.

Kennedy should come in because he is a young kid who needs to develop in the seniors ala what all other clubs seem to do rather than looking at our 2nds and choosing the best from them... wiggo and mcgrath.

Deluca should be the out as is there a CHF less tough and equipped to take a grab in any Under 11's team in the state, let alone the AFL?

_________________
Stay tuned We're in for a BUMPY ride

If there are going to be any changes, and I'm leaning towards no changes, then you'd reckon they'd be:

Out: Saddington/Deluca
In: Kennedy

This all depends on how match fit Kennedy and Saddington are. Deluca should be in the twos learning how to ruck, but if Saddington can't assure anyone he's going to be any better next week, he needs to get himself right.

I think we are forgetting that Collingwood are a team full of big units especially down forward..Rocca is cleaning up Port as I type this.

In Kennedy, Livo....

Out..Dont know yet but not Bannister.....Bannister was good IMO and will be needed down back....

Rocca
Fraser
Tarrant
Travis Cloke..all playing up forward....thats some serious size...
Mclaren has to play and down back..did a good job vs Richmond and I would have Mclaren on Rocca or Fraser...

We dont need to be dropping tall players or we will have the old silly situation of some midget having to pick up Rocca like what usually happens.....

_________________
"When you have the attitude of a champion, you see adversity as your
training partner."
- Conor Gillen

Forgot about that... Livo for Deluca and Saddington v Kennedy in the match fitness stakes.

In: Kennedy
Out: DeLuca
PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The question has to be asked: who are you apologising to? DeLuca's legions of fans????

_________________
Love Cricket? Love me

In: Livingston, Bryan
Out: Deluca, Saddington

_________________

************************************************************
NOW YOU'RE JUST SOME CLUB THAT I USED TO KNOW.

hate to say it but next week could get ugly, very very very ugly indeed.

I hate being so negative all the time about DeLuca that's all.

_________________
Witty signature required.

well, we could use a bit of variety on the site, I suppose

_________________
Love Cricket? Love me

Deluca & Bentick out, Kennedy & Blackwell in.

Can't believe Bentick never gets mentioned in any posts. For mine he is not up to it and his stats on Friday night do not warrant him retaining his spot.

I think to win we need more pace and versatility in the side.
In McGrath and Kennedy
Out Deluca and Saddington

I think Bentick had a bad game and would be dropped before Bannister plus Bannister adds more versatility to the team and could play as another tall defender or run with player.

McGrath Thornton McLaren
Walker Whitnall Bannister
Simpson Stevens Russell
Lappin Waite Murphy
Fisher Fevola Betts
French Koutifides Houlihan
Kennedy Bentick Scotland Carrazzo

out : Deluca , Scotland(inj), Saddington, Pagan(ooops thats next week after collingwood thumps us by 100 points after he insists that whitnall and Fevola double team Rocca!!!!!)


in : Kennedy(its time), Mcgrath and Livo

_________________
#sayerscouldbetheman!!

Changed my mind

In: Kennedy, Blackwell, Livingston
Out: Deluca, Russell, Saddington

We'll need Livo to play on Rocca

De Luca is a definite out - I thought some of his marking attempts were feeble to say the least. If contact from the smallest Tiger on the ground is enough to make him drop the ball at his size, then he isn't ever going to make it. Tyrants will acknowledge that I defend 'Big Campo' quite often but he was shocking on Friday night.

I think the whole mismatch theory only works if he can grab a mark. Perople denigrate Bryan but at least he can do that. If we really must have a mismatch by height then go for that. But if you cactually want a marking target then play someone who is a natural footballer like Kennedy, a guy who'll be with us for 10 years, not 18 more rounds.

This is a must and if they don't do it I'll spew horrible orange projectiles over the wall.

On Bentick - I think we're trying to make him something he isnt/ His 2005 was built on hard tackling on a key opponent - thus his near BOG against the Tigers lat year. he's not an uncontested footy player. bentick should be played as a hard tag on Coughlan, but wasn't.

in - McGrath, Kennedy, Livo.

Out - DeLuca, Saddo, Banno.

_________________
The only way for some people to understand is for them to be on the receiving end

Left wing moralists
In self serving denial
They shit me no end

I think Bannister is a must keep. His claim to fame is beating Buckley before - we have to give him the chance to maintain that sort of role. If he can't do it then we know where he will end up, and well, Bannister is at least a hrad running hard-trying player. I think he is too loose on many opponents but I'd keep him in this week. Single game stays in the 1's should be outlawed.