Jarusa wrote:
The Old Dark Navy's wrote:
No need to give credit Jarusa. You know I was inspired to start that thread.


I couldn't resist.
Both polls are exactly the same. At the moment there are 55 votes in the TC one and 54 in the
BF poll.
Melb voters with voting rights, 41% BF, 49% TC
Long distance with voting rights, 11% BF, 16% TC
Members as a % of poll voters, 81% BF, 89% TC
Looks like my guess was correct.

Hmmm, considering you were responding to an all out attack on Carlton posters by someone else, I'd say the results are not as conclusive as one might have thought. More posters post on more than one site these days, the main difference in my opinion being that the young and ignorant are less likely to survive talking issues on TC as they are quickly weeded out and exposed. I'm not having a go by the way, I too have been surprised with the influx of posters on BigFooty, and a lot of them seemingly new posters that hadn't really looked at the net as a serious vehicle for a Carlton fix before. I'm also surprised to see that the members and voters are holding up well in that poll. I thought it would be a lot lower.
I just think it is dangerous to split the supporter group into those in the know vs the ignorant supporters, especially along site lines. We all have our share of quality and problem children ... part of the rich tapestry I guess.