zeecfc wrote:
Murphy is the only A grader with elite capabilities we have on the list. You can maybe replace Henderson and Yarran's output but let's not get fanciful with trades and draft picks.
Don't agree. Murphy is a good player and I like the way he goes about it but IMO there is nothing elite about him.
The question I have is if we don't look at trading and draft picks to rebuild our list what do we do?
People keep saying we can't trade this player or that player because we need them. I reckon that is BS. Look where we are, our whole list is poor. We seem to overrate our players.
Whatever we think Murphy Gibbs Kruezer Jamison Casboult Thomas Tuohy Bell will still be at the club next year. There is enough experience there to lead the next generation. With Cripps Graham Buckley Docherty Holman Jaksch Smith Giles all emerging we now need to add as many potential young elite players to our list and IMO the only real way is through the draft and by giving something up.
We may be able to sneak an Aish with a pick 20ish but that's rare.
3-4 Top 25 picks (used properly) along with 2-3 others can give our list a whole different look.
3 years of some smart tough decisions and we can be back up the top. I hope.
If we tend to overate our players, then how do we trade them and get what we perceive as good value for them? Lets not even go down the track of considering our draft strike rate. Lets say trade murphy for pick 10 ish, then pick up a Lucas. Yeah right. Great deal. Its all a lay down misere in discussions like this, that we will all of a sudden be able to hit the draft out of the ball park. But the reality is, it is not that easy. There is no quick fix. A rebuild should happen methodically over 4-5 draft seasons, and must be accompanied by the requisite drafting competance. Like supplementing our existing core players with young skilled highly motivated and determined men. Dont trade our top players to scratch an itch, trade them when they are being chased and we can get overs for them. If our better players are struggling it is hardly the time to trade them.... When we will get the least value fir them. Surely a better strategy is to get the best out of them by developing our list properly and giving them some support. Not everyone can be a Judd or GAJ